Insurance Agent Recruiting Specialist

October 27, 2026
Toledo, OH, US
$40,000 – $85,000/yr
Know someone at Buckeye Growth Partners?
Opens a LinkedIn search of your own network. We never see your connections.

Job Overview

Welcome to Buckeye Growth Partners, where we believe that our greatest asset is our people. Located in the heart of Toledo, Ohio, we are growing quickly and looking for someone special to help us find the next generation of insurance experts. We aren't just filling desks here; we are building a community of consultants who are truly passionate about helping clients protect what matters most. As our Insurance Agent Recruiting Specialist, you will be the face of our firm for prospective hires. You will have the unique opportunity to shape the future of our team by seeking out individuals who possess a hunger for learning and a genuine desire to serve others. You will spend your days connecting with talented people, sharing the vibrant culture we have cultivated in Toledo, and showing them why they should choose to build their careers alongside us. We value an inviting atmosphere where your voice matters, your ideas are heard, and your contributions directly impact the reach and strength of our firm. If you have an eye for talent and a friendly, persistent approach to building relationships, we would be thrilled to talk with you about joining our journey.

Salary Range: $40,000.00 - $85,000.00 per year

Benefits

Annual Base Salary + Bonus Opportunities

Paid Time Off (PTO)
Flexible Schedule
Health Insurance
Dental Insurance
Vision Insurance
Life Insurance
Disability Insurance
Hands on Training
Mon-Fri Schedule
Career Growth Opportunities
Retirement Plan

Requirements

Property & Casualty Insurance License

Strong understanding of the insurance industry and its various licensing requirements.

Excellent verbal communication skills with the ability to convey company vision clearly.

Experience using applicant tracking systems and modern sourcing tools.

Self-motivated personality with a drive to build deep professional networks.

High school diploma or equivalent; Bachelor's degree in Human Resources or related field is a plus.

Responsibilities

Identify and engage with talented individuals who show potential to thrive in the insurance consulting field.

Conduct initial conversations to understand candidate goals and align them with our internal growth opportunities.

Guide prospective agents through our hiring process, ensuring they feel informed and supported from the first touchpoint.

Build and maintain a consistent pipeline of high-quality talent through proactive networking and community involvement.

Collaborate with our leadership team to refine our search strategies and identify the types of skills that contribute most to our long-term success.

Share the story and mission of Buckeye Growth Partners to attract candidates who share our values.

About Us

Farmers Insurance District Office - Northern Ohio

(Toledo, Columbus, Cleveland)